Part 9 of 13 part feature where we ask members for their views on resolutions for the contact center industry. Today's resolution: lGet rid of measures for front line professionals like average call duration and focus more on customer satisfaction scores and report these to the executives
"Good, executive need it for Decision Support System"
"Agreed - my centres do have AHT as KPI but only for reference and guideline towards achieving professionalism. Main KPIs are on scoring of Quality Assurance Assessment, Service Level as well occupancy and absentism."
- Zaliha Awang, Head of 999 Response Centre, Telekom Malaysia, Malaysia
"For newbies, average call duration should not be the focus. I will prefer to have a balance between productivity and customer satisfaction"
"My shop reports to the executive dashboard daily. Date includes calls offered, calls completed and speed of answer."
- Yvonne Parker, Call Center - Operations Manager, Cleveland Clinic, United States
"To some extent i agree to the idea but then again in the emerging contact center markets, removing the meaures altogether might not be good idea. however, we can analyze the impact in a step by step approach, offcourse alongwith CSAT benchmarks / scores."
- Hunain Bin Bashir, Manager BPO Operations, Ufone, Pakistan
"AHT is one good parameter but this shouldn't become a major KRA for the professional. Infact the present system allows good amount of deviation if the customer has more questions \ not satisfied etc.,"
- Lakshminarasimha K, Regional Manager, Infosys, India
"It should be a combination of front line performance and customer satisfaction :- currently,companies are looking at contact centre set up to provide customer service support vs walk-in customer service : to ensure effectiveness, we will need to measure front line performance to ensure at least 80% of the customers calls are answered effectively"
"Well, this has been talked about for a long time now. Call duration is linked to customer satisfaction. However, this can be a 2-edged sword. Depending on the industry, this needs to be balanced with many factors such as FL professional's efficiency and call volume. One way is to analyse the type of calls which entail long duration and then provide solutions."
- Alice Ho, Customer Service Director, TNT Express, Singapore
"Good & Bad, you can never get rid of these completely, they are important when you drill down to the reasons, however you can remove them from the leading indicators /KPI's"
"There still has to be a balance between statistical information like call duration, service level and other metrics given to executives because our front-line professionals don't control all aspects of the customer experience. Executives need to understand the customer frustration from long hold times, puzzling menus and even the quality problems that customers may face."
- Penny Lewis, Manager, Customer Satisfaction and Quality, Intermec, United States
"Good and Bad. The customer satisfaction is key but the average call duaration is a measurement to identify the area with potential improvement. Professionals spend one hour with the customers to tell them how to use a product and keep the customers happy at the very beginning is for sure. However, how to change the deisgn or to provide the right information to the customers without getting them call and stay on the phone would not be professional anymore."
"Average call duration is a measure of efficiency, not effectivenes. Both are important and have a place in the measurement of an agent's performance, though call duration may not be the most important such measure."
- Stephen Dawson, Vice President of Communication & Strategic Planning, The Heritage Company, United States
"Effective call control that results in a happy customer is always more valuable than compliance with a clock"
- Leanne Onstott, Call Center Director, Art.com, United States
"There is a need to differentiate between performance indicators and operational metrics that are essential in planning and managing the future. It is not as simple as simply removing these measures but they do not need to be shared with executives. Use the data wisely."
- Martin Jukes, Management Consultant, Mpathy Plus, United Kingdom
"Gosh, focusing on customer satisfaction. Do we actually want to sell anything"
"Agreed. A list of preferable measures need to be introduced i.e. % first call resolution"
- Erin Southworth, Director of Service, Service Impact, Australia
"Good and bad. Long average call duration drives costs in many ways."
- Tony Puskarik, IT Manager - Voice, Connextions, Inc, United States
"Makes total sense."
- Katie S. Burdorf, Partner, WDG Consulting, LLC, United States
"Disagree, Some measure such as GOS are certainly not measurements that staff should be managed by, however call duratoins, wrap times, adherence levels are vital components of being able to effectively manage a call centre and these are all things that staff have control over. Use of proper call control, adequate note taking and being in the proper mode are essential parts of consultants roles."
"Undecided - Both measurements have a place in the business - one drives efficiency, the other customer service - together they drive the direction of the business in terms of profitability efficiency and customer service."
- Ardiela Savahl, Group Customer Service Manager, Goodyear, South Africa
"I do not completely agree. Yes, CSat scores should be values the most and that should be the sole effectiveness KPI however, call duration translates in terms of cost as well. We need to be effective and efficient both. What can be done is that the Avg Call Duration should be given less weightage in KPIs but lets not take it out."
"Bad - unfortunately time-based measures are cost-based measures and, especially as an outsourcer, the focus to get the job done faster and better is always front-of-mind"
- Gabriel Fulton, Vice President Strategy and Growth, OCIS Group, Australia
"Absolutely. AHT/Avg. call duration is an input and should never be an output measure. Have thresholds to review with staff as it impacts staffing and call levels but don't use it to reward/penalize your staff. Instead focus on customer experience and getting it right first time for the customer and the business."
- Divyan Gupta, Senior Associate Vice President, Centrica Plc., India
"bad- BPO earnings are based on AHT and Quality scores, you score high in both, customer satisfaction also follows, stakeholders are also satisfied."
"It is good to ensure that the customer are being attended and there is no hurry. The front line professionals need to ensure that they answer all the calls promptly and should be trained enough to resolve all the complaints or issues faster in order to take other calls keeping mind all the customers are equally important. They should be no show haste while answering the calls."
"Not sure if we are prepared to get rid of this framework, I preffer to start includding new metrics and see how professionals work with the new ones. step by step"
- Jose Rodas, Call Center - Manager, atento guatemala, Guatemala
"Agreed. We are moving towards this practice. It's Quality that Counts!"
- Pauline Low, Senior Manager and Head, Contact Center, NTUC INCOME , Singapore
"It should still be a combination of these 2 metrices."
- Jacqueline Chin, Manager, Data Synergo, Malaysia
"This may work or may not work well. I have my own doubts as it may be misused and CSAT survey are taken once a year."
- Vummitti Lakshmi Narayana, GM Operations, Primoris, India
"Call duration is a budget and planning measure that cannot be ignored. However coaching to the right behaviors ie call control, vs call duration is more effective"
- Patti Thomas, Sales and Service Operations Manager, Eastlink, Canada
"Good- Focusing more on call duration drives the wrong behavior as experience has shown that professionals rash customers and first contact resolution is compromised and this translates in customer dissatisfaction"
- Sanyu Kibuuka, Call Center - Manager, MTN, Uganda
"i agree - we still use ACW and Ave Talk Time, etc. to keep technicians focused. We consider they types of support they are performing."
- Phyllis Wasmuth, Support Center Manager, CH2M HILL, United States
"Would like to focus on having effective leading KPIs that delivers the business objectives."
Don't have a current membership with ContactCenterWorld.com?
become a member and connect with the rest of the Contact Center Industry at ContactCenterWorld.com here
Forum Profile
Job Title:
(Display this on the Forum)
Company:
(Display this on the Forum)
Neither the Administrators of these forums, or the Moderators participating, are responsible for the privacy practices of any user. Remember that all information that is disclosed in these areas becomes public information and you should exercise caution when deciding to share any of your personal information. Any user who finds material posted by another user objectionable is encouraged to contact us via e-mail. We are authorized by you to remove or modify any data submitted by you to these forums for any reason we feel constitutes a violation of our policies, whether stated, implied or not.
This site may contain links to other web sites and files. We have no control over the content and can not ensure it will not be offensive or objectionable. We will, however, remove links to material that we feel is inappropriate as we become aware of them.
By pressing the "Agree" button, you agree that you, the user, are 13 years of age or over. You are fully responsible for any information or file supplied by this user. You also agree that you will not post any copyrighted material that is not owned by yourself or the owners of these forums. In your use of these forums, you agree that you will not post any information which is vulgar, harassing, hateful, threatening, invading of others privacy, sexually oriented, or violates any laws.
If you do agree with the rules and policies stated in this agreement, and meet the criteria stated herein, proceed to press the "Agree" button below, otherwise press "Cancel".
If you have any questions about this privacy statement or the use of these forums, you can contact the forum administrator at: rajw@contactcenterworld.com