News : Concerns Over Any Future Outsourcing at County Council
West Sussex County, UK, September, 2015 -- Concerns over further outsourcing of services at West Sussex County Council were raised during a debate on a programme to improve customer services.
The council’s Performance and Finance Select Committee discussed the new Customer Experience Programme, which will aim to deliver a better and more consistent service, and allow residents to do more online, reducing the amount of phone calls the authority receives.
However, councillors focused on the plans for a new customer services hub, and what scope there was for further outsourcing, as Capita already runs the county council’s contact centre.
Officers explained at last Thursday’s meeting that the changes would affect around 470 staff, and in time some might want to move to part-time contracts, or be employed directly by Capita.
Dan Sartin, UNISON branch secretary, said that while the union was in favour of excellent customer service, he questioned any moves that would further embed Capita into the county council’s ways of working, making any contract with the company ‘too big to fail’.
At a time when the motivation of Capita staff was ‘poor’ and WSCC was already examining the ‘underperforming’ contract, he felt they needed to ‘pause for thought’ before ‘putting all their eggs in one basket’.
Mr Sartin added: "Why are we not looking harder at how we can do these things in-house?"
But Bob Lanzer (Con, Maidenbower), WSCC’s cabinet member for corporate relations, said there was ‘no mass outsourcing’ planned in the option they were recommending, and that the primary driver was improving customer satisfaction and experience, rather than savings.
Peter Lamb (Lab, Northgate and Three Bridges) asked why they were making changes at a time when they were resetting the Capita contract, raised concerns over a lack of real key performance indicators and questioned the need for a ‘wide ranging programme without a wide ranging problem’.
He asked: "Is it acceptable to sign off a wide ranging review when we do not really know what we are talking about yet?"
Responding to a mention of department store John Lewis’ high customer satisfaction levels, Mr Lamb said: "It’s a lot easier to deliver a sofa than figure out people’s social care arrangements."
Cathryn James, executive director for residents’ services at WSCC, responded: "We are not saying we have the ultimate 99 per cent of it nailed down, but we have a significant percentage of it nailed down."
She explained how they were looking at Capita’s performance internally and added: "We need to start somewhere and we think this will deliver instant benefits."
Concern was not limited to opposition members as Steve Waight (Con, Goring) said he would have expected to see the investment and savings for each of the three options, and a detailed breakdown of the savings.
He added: "It just surprises me that information is available and not in the report. We have percentages that are meaningless and not the figures."
Deborah Urquhart (Con, Angmering and Findon), chairman of the committee, summed up members’ concerns over a lack of detail and data. A vote to support the new customer services model was tied, but then a second vote to support the changes ‘in principle’, subject to seeing the full figures at the next meeting, was passed.
Louise Goldsmith (Con, Chichester West), leader of WSCC, said: "The most important thing is people are comfortable around the financial detail. It’s a major commitment for this county council and I would rather it was held over."
Posted by Veronica Silva Cusi, news correspondent
Today's Tip of the Day - Loyalty Versus Satisfaction
About West Sussex County Council:
West Sussex County Council (WSCC) is the authority that governs the non-metropolitan county of West Sussex.
Published: Monday, September 21, 2015