News : Training of Staff at NHS 111 Call Centre ‘Not Fit for Purpose'
London, UK, Jan 21, 2016 -- Patients were put at risk by a reliance on "inexperienced staff" working without proper supervision at a 111 call centre exposed by the Telegraph, an official review has found.
An internal inquiry concluded that training of new recruits to the NHS helpline was "not fit for purpose", while underqualified recruits were being used as "stop-gaps" to cover shifts due to staff shortages.
The report by South Central Ambulance Service into concerns raised by a Telegraph investigation last year found that the time spent on coaching call handlers at its call centre fell short of NHS guidance after being "condensed" by the centre's manager.
It concluded that an undercover reporter working at the centre "was not adequately supervised" after being left to take calls from patients following just four weeks' training.
The inquiry also found that some staff had not raised concerns about problems because of a "repressive" manager at the call centre in Oxfordshire. The manager has now been replaced.
The ambulance trust launched an internal inquiry after an undercover Telegraph reporter, who spent seven weeks working as a call handler, found that amid a shortage of paramedics, call handlers were being put under pressure not to send out ambulances at certain times.
Staff with only four weeks' training were relying on a computer system to decide whether patients with a range of illnesses should receive ambulances or be sent to hospital or their GP.
In one case our reporter was unable to send a crew to a man suffering from chest pains, because he could not be sure about the cause of his symptoms. The computer’s decision was upheld by a medic at the centre and the man was told he would be contacted by a GP instead.
The ambulance service's report attempted to blame the reporter for the incident. However it admitted that there was "a lack of suitable and adequate governance" at the time in May and June 2015.
The reporter did not have a dedicated coach, leading to "inconsistent messages and confusion".
"From a patient safety point of view this practice must be a risk as the service is relying on inexperienced staff, who have not yet qualified as solo operators, to cover shifts, usually of high demand," the report concluded.
A separate report by the Care Quality Commission said SCAS denied any of the problems identified by the Telegraph compromised the "safety" of the service. But the trust acknowledged that "issues had been identified during the course of the investigation which did give cause for concern". There had been "an increase of coaching and supervision" following the investigation
Posted by Veronica Silva Cusi, news correspondent
Today's Tip of the Day - Web Offers
More Editorial From NHS Direct
About NHS Direct:
NHS Direct is a 24 hour health advice and information service provided by the National Health Service (NHS) in England. NHS Direct provides confidential access to medical information, guidance and reassurance through a range of interactive services. These include an expert telephone advice line and detailed web resources.
Published: Monday, January 25, 2016